CE marked · ISO 9001:2015 · 18-month warranty

Technical notes · · 7 min read

Single screw or twin screw: the decision in numbers

Mixing, dispersion, cost per kg/h and maintenance — where the extra 2.5× investment in a twin screw actually goes.

Compact twin screw masterbatch granulator for single versus twin screw comparison

For plain PP or PE regrind, a single screw is the right machine: lower cost per kg/h, easier maintenance, and 0.28–0.42 kWh/kg. Move to a twin screw when the product needs dispersion rather than melting — filler above 15%, glass fibre, flame retardant, or colour that must not show specks in a 20 µm film.

What the twin screw does that the single cannot

  • Distributive and dispersive mixing in the same pass, with interchangeable kneading blocks
  • 70% filler loading without burning the carrier, via separate side feeding
  • Two-stage devolatilisation at high surface renewal, for 5,000 ppm volatiles
  • Self-wiping screws: no dead zones, so colour change takes 40 minutes instead of 3 hours

Cost comparison at equal output

Item Single screw 600 kg/h Twin screw 600 kg/h
Machine price (FOB) US$28,000 US$68,000
Installed power 132 kW 160 kW
Specific energy 0.32 kWh/kg 0.28 kWh/kg
Wear parts per year US$7,000 US$14,000
Colour change 2–3 hours 40–60 minutes

When the twin screw pays back

If you sell compound at a US$150/t premium because dispersion is better, 600 kg/h × 6,000 h = 3,600 t a year, or US$540,000 of extra margin — the price difference disappears in weeks. If you sell plain recycled pellet at commodity prices, it never pays back. The decision is commercial, not technical.

Questions buyers ask

Can a single screw make masterbatch?

At 10–20% pigment with a static mixer, yes, for low-end applications. Above 30% the dispersion is not good enough for thin film, and the pellet will show agglomerates.

Which is easier to maintain?

Single screw: one screw, one barrel, bearings every 3–5 years. Twin screw: screw elements are replaceable individually, but there are more of them and gearbox rebuilds are specialist work.

Keep reading

Technical notes

العربيةAR